Understanding ICE in Clinical Practice: Why It Matters and How to Get It Right

Today, let us talk about ICE! and no, not the frozen kind. I-C-E stands for Ideas, Concerns, and Expectations. If you are a clinician in active practice, this simple framework can radically improve your patient interactions, help you deliver more person-centred care, and potentially save you from complaints.

Let me explain.

One of the most common reasons patients end up reporting clinicians or filling out complaints is not because we were rude, or even because our clinical skills were poor but because we failed to meet their expectations. And in many cases, that is because we never actually asked what they were expecting in the first place.

So what is ICE-ing a patient?

To ICE a patient means to explore:

• I – What are their Ideas about what is going on?

• C – What are their Concerns about this issue?

• E – What are their Expectations for the consultation?

Sounds simple, right? But here is the tricky bit: many patients find these questions awkward. You ask, “What do you think is causing your pain?” and the response might be: “Well, you’re the expert. That’s why I’m here!” Or you ask, “What are you hoping we can do today?” and they reply: “To get better, of course.”

That is why how you ask ICE matters.

Tone, rapport, and phrasing make a huge difference. Patients may feel a bit “on the spot” if you ask these questions bluntly, especially now that some are starting to catch on to the term “ICE.” You do not want to sound like you are checking boxes or following a script. No one wants to feel like they are being “iced.”

So how do you do it naturally?

You find ways to weave these questions into the flow of your conversation. For example:

• Instead of “What’s your concern?”, you could ask:

“Is there anything you’ve been particularly worried about that you’d like me to talk through today?”

• Instead of “What are your expectations?”, try:

“Apart from going over your symptoms, is there anything else you were hoping we’d cover today?”

These open, softer ways of asking can help patients open up without even realising they are being “iced.” And here’s the beauty once you create a safe, comfortable space, many patients will volunteer their ICE naturally. You just have to listen.

Why ICE is more than just a communication tool

ICE is the meeting point between two mindsets: the patient’s and the clinician’s. The patient comes in with their own thoughts, fears, and hopes. You, as the clinician, also come in with your own clinical agenda your need to assess, diagnose, and treat. ICE helps you bridge that gap.

When you explore a patient’s ideas, you might find clues that help your diagnostic reasoning. Their concerns may point to yellow flags those psychosocial factors that increase the risk of chronicity or delayed recovery. And when you know their expectations, you can manage them. Sometimes it is about gently correcting unrealistic hopes. Other times, it is about offering reassurance and showing them you are on their side.

Here is a quick breakdown:

• Ideas: What do they think is causing their symptoms? Sometimes they have a guess; other times, they do not. Either way, this tells you a lot about their understanding and whether they need education or clarity.

• Concerns: What are they worried about, and why? This is crucial. If someone fears they have a brain tumour, the why might be that their mother died of one. Or maybe a friend had MS and they are seeing similar symptoms. Digging into that why gives you an opportunity to explore, exclude serious pathology, and reassure.

• Expectations: What do they want from the consultation? It might be a scan, a referral, or just peace of mind. Even if you cannot meet their exact expectations, you can negotiate. Maybe you cannot give a scan, but you can offer a blood test, or explain clearly why observation is the best next step.

Sometimes all three elements come out early in the conversation. Other times, you have to explore them bit by bit. And remember: ICE is not always in separate boxes. A patient’s idea might also be their concern. For example, if someone believes their back pain is due to cancer, that is both their idea and their fear. Be sensitive to that.

In conclusion…

ICE is not just a tick-box exercise. It is the foundation of a strong, person-centred consultation. When done well, it makes your patient feel heard, understood, and respected. And from your end, it leads to better clinical reasoning, safer practice, and fewer complaints.

So my biggest tip? Build rapport. When the relationship is strong, patients will give you their ICE without you even needing to ask.

And that, my friend, is the sweet spot of great clinical care.

If you found this helpful and you want more practical tools to level up your clinical game, check out my e-books:
👉 Visit selar.com/m/adebolabadiru

From MSK assessment blueprints to guides on writing strong supporting info and killer CVs, you will find resources that actually make a difference in your day-to-day practice.